Before asking what you did, remember who you are

When a person falls, the first question is usually: what did you do? But sometimes the question that opens the door to deeper repentance is: do you remember who you are?

A grandfather does not give his struggling grandson a lecture. He opens a family album and shows him where he comes from: a home, a people, a Torah, a belonging. Only then does he ask: do you remember who you are?

Haazinu says: “For the Lord’s portion is His people” (Deuteronomy 32:9). Before the demand comes identity. Before criticism comes belonging.

A sin is real and responsibility is real, but a person is not the sum total of his worst actions. The moment he says “this is just who I am,” he turns an action into an identity and closes the door to change.

Teshuvah is not self-hatred. It is the moment a person remembers that his actions do not fit the person he seeks to be.

Before asking how much you damaged, remember what is still sacred inside you.

Do you see your failure as something you did - or as a definition of who you are?

Read in depth

They tell of a young man from a very respected family who began to deteriorate. At first it was small things, then more troubling reports began reaching home. His father tried everything. He spoke with him, became angry with him, warned him, explained what he was destroying for himself and how much pain he was causing the family. Nothing helped. The more the father spoke, the more the son closed himself off. He already knew by heart every speech that was about to come.

One day the grandfather asked to speak with his grandson. Everyone expected that he too would give him a sharp mussar talk, but the grandfather did not mention even one of the things the young man had done. He took an old photo album from the cupboard and began showing him pictures. Here is your great-grandfather. Here is the synagogue where the family prayed. Here is your father when he was your age. Here is your bar mitzvah. Here is a picture of you as a child standing beside the Torah scroll. They sat like that for a long time, until the grandfather closed the album and said: “I am not going to tell you what you did. You know it better than I do. I want to ask you only one question: do you remember who you are?”

The young man did not answer. The grandfather continued: “I am not telling you that you have to be like me or like your father. I am telling you only one thing. Before you decide where you are going, do not forget where you come from and what you belong to. Because a person who forgets who he is can reach places that a person who remembers who he is would never imagine reaching.”

Sometimes a mussar talk that begins with “What did you do?” causes a person immediately to defend himself. He explains, justifies, blames circumstances. But there is a question much harder to escape: does the way I am living fit the person I know I am?

In the Song of Haazinu, Moses says: “For the Lord’s portion is His people; Jacob is the lot of His inheritance” (Deuteronomy 32:9). This verse appears within a song that contains very severe rebuke. Moses is about to speak about falls, ingratitude, and distancing from God, but before he reaches all of that he establishes a fundamental fact: “For the Lord’s portion is His people.”

That order is not accidental. Before Moses tells Israel what they may do, he reminds them who they are. Before rebuke comes identity. Before sin comes belonging. The Torah does not say: if you are perfect, perhaps you will become God’s portion. It says: you are God’s portion, and now the question is how a person who belongs to the Holy One, blessed be He, is meant to live.

Rashi explains that the Holy One, blessed be He, chose Jacob and his children as His portion (Deuteronomy 32:9). There is here a choice and a belonging that precede the behavior of a particular moment. This does not cancel responsibility. On the contrary, it creates a far deeper responsibility. When a person knows he belongs to something great, he begins to ask whether his actions fit that belonging.

This can change the entire way we approach Shabbat Shuvah. Usually, when people say “the Ten Days of Repentance,” a person immediately begins making a list of what is wrong: where did I fail, what did I not do, what do I need to fix? Of course self-examination is necessary. But perhaps before the list of failures, one sentence should be written at the top of the page: “For the Lord’s portion is His people.”

Before I ask what I ruined, I need to remember who did the ruining. Not a worthless person from whom nothing is expected, but a soul that belongs to the Holy One, blessed be He. Not someone whom the Torah has already given up on, but someone from whom the Torah demands because it believes in his ability to live higher.

This is a very deep point in repentance. Sometimes a person thinks that teshuvah requires him to convince himself how terrible he is. But if the entire process is built only on self-humiliation, it is very easy to reach despair. A person says to himself: I failed again; again I did not keep what I accepted upon myself; again I reached Yom Kippur with the same things. Apparently this is simply who I am.

The Torah says: no. Sin is something you did, but it does not have to become the definition of who you are.

Maimonides writes something remarkable in the laws of repentance about a baal teshuvah. He says that repentance brings near those who were distant, and that a person who was far away can become beloved and pleasant, close and dear before God (Mishneh Torah, Hilkhot Teshuvah 7:6). In other words, Torah does not see a person as permanently sealed inside the place he has reached. He can return, because the deeper relationship has not disappeared.

We can understand this through something simple from family life. A child does something very serious. His father can be extremely angry, set boundaries, and demand repair, but underneath all that anger one fact remains unchanged: this is my child. Precisely because he is my child, I care so much about what he does. If he were a stranger, perhaps I would simply move on. Belonging does not cancel the demand. Belonging is the reason the demand is so deep.

That is how we can understand the days of repentance. The Holy One, blessed be He, does not tell us: repair yourselves so that I can decide whether you belong to Me. He calls us to return because we belong to Him.

That also changes the language with which a person speaks to himself. Instead of saying, “I am an angry person,” he can say, “There is anger in me that I need to work on.” Instead of “I am a person who cannot pray,” say, “My prayer needs repair.” Instead of “That is just who I am,” say, “This is where I am now, but it does not have to be where I remain.”

There is an enormous difference between a person who says “I failed” and a person who says “I am a failure.” The first sentence can lead to repentance. The second can close the door in its face.

Perhaps this is one of the most dangerous weapons of the evil inclination. Before the sin it tells a person: it is not so terrible. After the sin it changes language and says: now look who you really are. Before the sin it minimizes the act; after the sin it magnifies it until it turns it into the person’s identity. In both cases the goal is the same: that you should not get up.

But the Torah says: “For the Lord’s portion is His people.” Do not let a fall tell you the whole story about yourself.

There is a remarkable verse in Micah: “Do not rejoice over me, my enemy; though I have fallen, I rise; though I sit in darkness, the Lord is light for me” (Micah 7:8). The verse does not say, “I did not fall.” It says exactly the opposite: “Though I have fallen.” The fall is real. There is no denial. But immediately afterward: “I rise.” The fact that I fell does not determine that I will remain on the floor.

This may be one of the most important questions of Shabbat Shuvah: am I making a self-examination in order to discover how far I am, or in order to discover what step will bring me back to who I really am?

A person can stand on Yom Kippur and say, “We have been guilty, we have betrayed, we have robbed, we have spoken slander,” but we should notice to Whom he is saying all of this. He is standing before the Holy One, blessed be He. The confession itself is an act of relationship. I am not running away. I come to You with my failure because I believe the failure did not cancel my ability to stand before You.

Perhaps this is the depth of the word “we have betrayed.” Betrayal exists only where there was belonging. A stranger cannot betray me. Precisely because there is a relationship, it matters that I was not faithful to it. Therefore, even inside confession itself, a point of hope is hidden: if I can say “we have betrayed,” I am acknowledging that there is a covenant to which I want to return.

There is another verse in Haazinu that sharpens this point. Moses says: “Is He not your Father, who acquired you? He made you and established you” (Deuteronomy 32:6). Notice the first word: “your Father.” In the middle of severe rebuke, Moses does not allow Israel to forget before Whom they stand. There is judgment, responsibility, and demand, but the relationship is the relationship of a Father.

Repentance is therefore not merely an escape from sin. It is a return home.

That changes the way we can enter Yom Kippur. A person may arrive frightened by the list of his sins, and there is certainly a place for awe. But he can also arrive with a deep sense of belonging: Master of the universe, I know I did not always live as one who belongs to You should live, and that is why I am here. If I did not care about the relationship, I would not confess. If I thought I had nowhere to return to, I would not ask forgiveness.

Perhaps that is why one of the peaks of Yom Kippur is the moment when a Jew says again and again: “For we are Your people and You are our God; we are Your children and You are our Father; we are Your servants and You are our Master.” Before all explanations, there is a relationship. There is “we” and there is “You.” We remind ourselves to Whom we belong.

I would like each person to take only one question from this: if I remembered at every moment who I am and to Whom I belong, what decision in my life would look different?

How would I speak at home if, one second before the harsh word, I remembered who I am? How would I behave in business if I remembered who I am? What would I look at on my phone, and what would I not look at, if I remembered who I am? How would I pray, how would I treat someone weaker than me, and how would I react when my honor is hurt, if I asked not only “What am I permitted to do?” but also “What fits me?”

This is a different level of serving God. Not only searching for the red line beneath which it is forbidden to fall, but asking what is fitting for a person who is “the Lord’s portion.”

Perhaps this is what that grandfather was trying to tell his grandson. He did not ignore his actions. He knew very well what had happened. But he understood that if the boy came to think he was already a ruined person with no connection to who he had once been, every rebuke would push him farther away. So he opened an album and said: before we speak about what you did, let us remember who you are.

Shabbat Shuvah may be the album the Holy One, blessed be He, opens before us.

He reminds us where we came from, what covenant we belong to, what soul was placed within us, and what the Torah believes we are capable of becoming. Only from that place does He ask us to look honestly at the places where we grew distant.

Not in order to say: look how low you are.

But to ask: if you belong so high, why continue living lower than you are capable of?

“For the Lord’s portion is His people” is not a compliment. It is responsibility. But it is also enormous hope.

Because if I belong, I have somewhere to return to. If sin is not my entire identity, I can separate from it. And if the Holy One, blessed be He, is still calling me to return, then the door has not closed.

Perhaps the first resolution of Shabbat Shuvah should therefore not be: “I must become a different person.” Perhaps it should be deeper: I want to begin living like the person I really am.

Before you ask how far you went, remember where you came from.

Before you ask how much you damaged, remember what is still holy inside you.

And before you tell yourself, “That is just who I am,” hear Moses again saying to you: “For the Lord’s portion is His people; Jacob is the lot of His inheritance.”

Perhaps repentance begins exactly there.

Not in the moment when a person hates himself because of what he did, but in the moment when he remembers who he is, understands that his actions do not fit that identity, and decides to return to living at the height to which he belongs.